7 Pages are shown on the Main Page.

7 pages are shown on the Main Page. To see additional posts, click on the link "Older Posts" at the bottom of the main page. For videos go to https://www.youtube.com/@normanretzke4377/videos click "skip" to avoid ads


G has a "swell" time kayaking

G has a "swell" time kayaking
G has a "swell" time on Lake Michigan in an inflatable canoe

Dawn on the Gulf of Mexico

Dawn on the Gulf of Mexico
Dawn on the Gulf of Mexico

Warren Dunes Sunset

Warren Dunes Sunset
Warren Dunes Sunset

Tuesday, October 22, 2019

Cool and Cold Weather Trekking



A Snowman in New Orleans, Louisiana
Complete with hard hat and safety vest

Early morning in 19 ft. All-electric Sprinter after an 18F night.
G is making oatmeal with water heated on the electric cooktop,
Our first Trek, no microwave, just an electric cooktop, no furnace either
Just a small electric heater  - a real camping experience,
we have made some changes since then!

Bookmark and Share


Hint: Click on images to enlarge them.....





If you want to winter RV, well here is a possible vehicle,
 built on a PistenBully Snowtrak (Peterson Equipment Co).

We don't always plan to do winter camping - Winter Happens!
Winter happens, even in New Orleans LA there is sub freezing weather and snow, from time to time.  I've also encountered this in Charleston, SC. too, and so on. I've experienced snow in July, too. When trekking in the late fall or winter, it is quite likely we will encounter sub freezing weather for a day or a few days.

This post is about our experiences in cool to cold weather trekking and how we did it. We choose to be comfortable in the winter and we hope this post will provide you with some ideas, and that your winter treks are both fun and comfortable.

Some of our modifications accommodate hot weather trekking, too.  We may not plan on living in our Class B Roadtrek in below freezing weather, but we will travel with it in freezing weather and we have spent a few days in nighttime temperatures as low as 5 F.

I am not advocating living in a Roadtrek in continuous below freezing temperatures. There are practical issues to deal with, and this post points out some of them. I am writing that trekking comfortably in freezing conditions is possible.  Living in our Roadtrek 210P in sub freezing temperatures even for a few days has been a challenge. Open the door and that snow, sleet and cold enters our living domain.   Having plentiful hot and cold running water is a dream. However, we will and do encounter below freezing temperatures while trekking and our 210P has kept us comfortable. This post is about that kind of trekking, going from place to place and in the process encountering cold weather, and dealing with it in comfort. For example, our longest trek was 110 days, but we only encountered cold weather for a few of those. That was a combination of choice, and flexibility. We can and do escape the majority of the cold weather. "Have Roadtrek will Travel" LOL.

Read on to see how we deal with the limitations. I also point out that some of the things we do are advantageous to improved comfort during hot weather trekking. This is so because the issue we are dealing with is the outside temperature, both high and low, and extremes will impact our interior comfort.  Some methods to deal with those outside temperature extremes are equally effective in both hot and cold weather. Of course, in hot weather we aren't concerned with freezing water systems.

Experiences
Our first trek in our 210P put us into winter conditions because we simply couldn't escape to warmer weather fast enough. That's the reality when one treks in late fall or early winter. Weather has a way of intruding. Fortunately for me I've done a lot of winter tent camping. G on the other hand really loves the snow but wants to hunker down in front of a fireplace as soon as possible.

We've taken what we think is a realistic approach to our desires in trekking via our Roadtrek. If we travel in the early spring, the fall or early winter we should expect to encounter cold conditions. So it is best to prepare for it.  It's again that time of year and we are thinking of trekking and keeping comfortable in our Class B RV as the outside temperatures decrease. We are prepared. When trekking in winter conditions we do carry hats, hoodies, winter coats, scarf, gloves, warm socks and boots.  I even have a balaclava. This is as much as a preparation for breakdowns as for anything else.

Each year we encounter sub freezing weather. We have trekked and overnighted down to 5 F in our 2013 210P. That winter night was not planned, but we had prepared. Our 210P has kept us comfortable, but there were some things we had to figure out, and some things we did to improve the winter conditioning of the 210P. This included enhancements to active and passive temperature controls.

Our first cold weather experience was six years ago in a rental Class B in some of the National Parks in Utah. When nighttime fell below 20F, we had some difficulty keeping comfortable. Our only source of heat was a small electric heater, and we didn't have sleeping bags; just a down blanket. We learned from that experience and modified our approach. The 210P was a vital step in that. We have yet to use sleeping bags, because in our 210P they aren't necessary for us.


Winter at about 7500 ft elevation - " a real snot freezer"
June Morning
Walking at 10,600 feet elevation, in June

Comfort Factors
Temperature based comfort in a class B (or any RV, for that matter) is determined by a variety of factors. Comfort includes:
  • What we wear (dry clothing preferred),
  • Type of undergarments (wicking is better),
  • What we eat (warm foods, liquids and carbs in cool weather); good food makes winter weather far more enjoyable,
  • The amount of activity (more is better in cold weather),
  • The insulation in the RV (to assist in keeping interior temperatures moderate and reduce heat loss) in winter, and reduce heat gain in summer,
  • The amount of moisture in the air inside the RV (too much results in condensation in the winter, too much in summer is simply "sticky"),
  • The ventilation in our RV (to keep interior moisture under control). 
  • The energy sources available (for both heat and cooling),
  • Floor construction and carpeting.
  • Where we park. In daylight, that sunlight can help heat the RV. However, at night there is no solar heat available. In hot weather, we prefer the shade.
Furthermore, comfort is relative and subjective. Under high activity conditions in cold weather we are not nearly as susceptible to the environment as we are during periods of low activity. Burning calories releases heat, warms our muscles and improves our attitude.  The converse may be true in hot and humid weather conditions.  However, the focus of this post is cool to cold weather.

There was a time when they called Class Bs "Camper Vans" with limited amenities. Today some are being promoted at "Glamper Vans" and some include heated floors, etc. but there is still the weather to deal with. Open the door on your Glamper Van and you will get a dose of the winter reality you are travelling in.

My "Other" Camping Experience
Prior to roadtrekking I was a backpacker and ground camper. We camped for short periods in winter weather and I was trained and learned enough to be proficient at doing it and to pass what I learned to others.  Skill and technique really does make a difference. The lowest temperatures I experienced with such camping was -25F (-32C). That was definitely a challenge, because our only source of heat was a campfire! In my opinion the most comfortable winter camping was at about 10 to 15F (-10C) . At those temperatures humidity was low, air temperature was not in the "frigid" range, simple steps avoided frostbite and our warming campfires were adequate.  We could and did cook outdoors under those conditions. Of course we slept in sleeping bags. However, this post is not about that.

Our first cold weather trek - a learning experience
Cold weather is determined by geographical location and altitude.  When trekking we are changing both and at the higher altitudes we do encounter cooler weather. Of course there is the dreaded "Arctic Vortex" whatever that is.

Our first cold weather trek was not in our Roadtrek. It was in a rental Class B. This was an all-electric coach with a two burner electric stovetop. It had no propane,  no microwave and no furnace. Interior heat was from a small portable electric heater, or running the engine. We were pretty much dependent upon that 120VAC 30 ampere electrical connection and solar panels. That was an October experience in Utah at National Parks with temperature dipping below 20F at night. We learned a lot from that experience and it did require that G wear mittens inside. The trek was a wonderful experience, but I decided I wanted multiple energy sources in my Class B. G simply wanted more comfort. We used that experience to make a list of what we wanted and what we would do differently.

Heat, cooling and cooking is determined by Energy Sources Available.

Our second winter trek, in a multi-energy sourced Roadtrek
Our second trek, in the first week of December 2013 was interrupted by winter. That was not the plan, but our departure was delayed. This was to be our "shakedown" cruise in our newly purchased 210P. We were headed to Florida a week after purchase, but had to deal with the consequences of a sudden cold weather front. Yes, these things do happen when travelling from the Midwest to the South. It was a comfortable experience, but additional modifications, many simple,  have since made our trekking even more comfortable.

First winter overnight stop in the Roadtrek, kept warm with the generator and the propane furnace.
Getting ready for the morning departure.
Nietzschean Experiences?
We've put all that we've learned to good use. That includes my previous activities as a backpacker and cold weather camping advocate. However, G does not share my enthusiasm for this. So it has been my goal to do things that make our treks in hot and cold weather as comfortable as possible. One measure of my success is the fact that after six years of trekking, G is even more enthusiastic about this. No simple feat if you have arthritis.

The purpose of this blog is to share what we have learned. This post is about cool or cold weather trekking. It is not about winter survival, or living in our Roadtrek through the winter with subfreezing conditions. I assume the reader has a desire to be comfortable hot or cold, rain or shine. I also assume the reader wants to have functional plumbing......

Maintain the chassis and the coach 
It is important that the vehicle be maintained. This is the foundation of all treks and there are two aspects, the chassis and the coach.

We recently completed our 38,000 mile checkup at the Chevy dealer. This included:
  • Change engine oil (full synthetic) and filter, 
  • Check air cleaner,
  • Inspect tires, 
  • Rotate tires and reset TPMS (tire pressure monitoring system),
  • Check brakes,
  • Multi-point lubrication,
  • New windshield wipers,
  • Check and top off all fluids,
  • Check doors,
  • Inspect undercarriage,
  • Verify head lamps, taillights, etc. are functional.
I did my own coach inspections and we did the following:
  • Run hot water heater, inspect anode,
  • Flush and then winterize the water systems (fresh, black, grey),
  • Replace battery separator,
  • Test all interior hinges, latches and replace one,
  • Check coach batteries,
  • Clean entire interior,
  • Check backup camera and monitor,
  • Do monthly run of Onan generator and check oil level (not due for replacement),
  • Top off the propane tank (added 4.4 gallons at Tractor Supply),
  • Run the refrigerator and then clean the empty interior, new baking soda freshener,
  • Run the heat pump and furnace,
  • Run the overhead fan, clean. 
  • Verify Tripp Lite charger and inverter operation, 
  • Test all lamps,
  • New batteries for temperature monitors and CO monitor,
  • New batteries for portable lights
  • New batteries for refrigerator interior fan (an add-on),.
Our well equipped Class B
Our Roadtrek has the following. Some was original equipment and some we added. We use them all:
  • Heat Pump/Air conditioner (good heat to as low as about 40F) - 120VAC,
  • Propane Furnace (as long as there is 12VDC and propane, good to go) - 12VDC and Propane,
  • Ceramic portable heater 750 watt/1500 watt (which we added, and good if there is 120VAC),
  • Water heater - Propane,
  • Reflectix for windows (which we added, keeps heat in and reduces condensation on windows),
  • Circulating fan (which we added, distributes the heat and minimizes cold spots),
  • Electric blanket, dual zone (individual comfort settings, 120VAC)
  • Two-burner stovetop - Propane (we seldom use this),
  • Inductive electrical burner and cast iron skillets, etc. (which we added) - 120 VAC.
  • Screen for passenger side front window (home-made to improve summer ventilation and keep the bugs out. Our Roadtrek has a screen for the side door and one for the rear door. We have not yet used the one for the side door. 
  • Carpeting for the kitchen area. We use a "Quick Drying Memory Foam bath runner 24 x 58 inches". 
Class B Comfort Issues
For one thing, most Class Bs are not well insulated. Our Roadtrek 210P is about R-4.5 according to an email I received in response to my query to Roadtrek. However, single pane glass is about R-0.1 which is just about "nothing" as in "no insulating value". A Class B has a high percentage of glass, compared to the overall surface area of the RV.  That glass creates a constant struggle to maintain comfortable internal temperatures.  Heat escapes from the inside in winter, or comes from the outside to the inside during the summer.

According to the manufacturer, our Roadtrek was designed for 3-1/2 seasons. Well, yes, but one better know what they are doing if they want to trek outside the 3-season envelope and in sub freezing weather. The good thing is, these things can be learned, and a few techniques and modifications can help.

We realized that if we planned to trek comfortably below freezing that we would have to augment the insulation in our Roadtrek. After purchase we have trekked with nighttime temperatures as low as 0 F and daytime highs in the teens. We carry Reflectix cut for every window except the side entry, including the front windshield. We have also done other things to be comfortable in the cold and in the hot.

Reflectix is inexpensive.  I purchased a 50 ft x 48 inch roll. (I use it in three rigs).

Reflectix visible in the Passenger Door Window - cool, dry weather

Reflectix in the front windshield and a sunshade, too (during hot, full sun weather)
Issues - Be aware of conditions and limitations - Do not fight the weather!
Prudence dictates that we avoid really serious weather situations.  We check the weather frequently when cold weather trekking. Not only where we currently are and where we are going. We also check weather patterns that are bearing down on us in 24 hours and longer.  If there is a possibility of really bad weather G and I have an agreement that we will hunker down in a motel; we have yet to do that. In my opinion this is common sense.  We also make reservations when trekking. Of course, one can also hang out in a truck stop if necessary, and we have slept at rest stops and so on. For example, the Ohio Turnpike has limited areas for RVs at some official rest stops, which includes 120VAC 30/50A service for a fee.

I do need to point out that we have had reservations, were delayed en route, called the campground office and were told "No problem, the office will be closed but there will be an envelope with your campsite information on the bulletin board". Upon arrival we retrieved that information and drove to our site, only to find that someone else had taken it.   That can and will happen when weather conditions get ugly. Apparently under those situations those of us who don't plan are willing to hijack a spot in a campground. In our situations, we've been fortunate to find a place to park and we do have a generator. My point is, if you expect your fellow trekkers to keep their agreements, then dream on..... It is a jungle out there.....

Some states have limited capacity to deal with snow and ice. It is prudent to be mindful of that. We've trekked across north Texas at 25 MPH because of poor road conditions.  Something to keep in mind when making those time-to-distance calculations and destination arrival estimates.

We don't fight the weather. We sometimes take a long bypass, or delay our trek so as to avoid serious weather situations, or road conditions that we might not be comfortable in.  Those mountain passes are not fun in bad weather. We also will adjust our plans to accommodate reality.  Our goal is to eventually get to a warmer destination and we maintain our purpose.  When the weather does get "ugly" we stick to interstates or other very major roads. Breakdowns can and do happen and we don't want to be stranded on some seldom travelled two-lane highway going across 50 miles of prairie or whatever. Keep in mind that it is important to be accessible when issues do occur.

My mantra is "icy conditions must be avoided". We've encountered ice and when we do we stop. We have stopped and boondocked when freezing rain began and waited until the sun was up the next morning. After the roads had warmed and thawed did we resume our journey.  Many southern states have minimal snow removal equipment, don't use salt but prefer sand or "nothing". In those areas, people generally wait a day or two for the storms to pass and things to thaw. We do what the locals do.

I'll try to avoid North-South routes that cross what I call the "freeze line".  It is in that area that I've encountered some really poor travel conditions. So we'll head southerly and try to get below that weather line. However, sometimes those situations can go very far south, and they simply can't be avoided.  A few years ago I was driving from New Orleans to Chicago, and a cold front dumped rain in Louisiana and Mississippi was a complete icycle. I slept in a rest stop.  The next morning things were better, but not by much. It was a frozen landscape all the way north.

Here's a spring route we took, to see a few things and avoid some nasty weather:

From Arizona to Michigan and Illinois, via a circuitous, warmer route


Seldom travelled roads might not be the best route in winter weather


Fresh Water and grey and black tank limitations
If one is to winter trek, there are the issues of fresh water and how to deal with wastewater. That includes the black and grey tanks. In my opinion this is the primary limit to cold weather camping in  our Class B. It does not have heated tanks and most piping is not protected or insulated from the cold. If the pipes and tanks freeze expensive damage can be the result. This does severely limit our ability to live "full time" in our 210P in cold weather unless there are other means and sources for fresh water, and a nearby heated toilet and shower.

If it is continually below freezing, the only way to get fresh water into my Roadtrek is to put it into smaller containers, such as a 1-1/2 gallon container in the photo, and store it inside. (More on the interior fresh water tank later in the post). Some campgrounds do provide water to a heated spigot (our experience in Breckenridge CO, for example) but the heat tape stops at the valve, and the whole contraption is in an insulated box. Even if I had an electrically heat traced fresh water hose, my Roadtrek would still freeze. 

Portable Water Container
We Winterize if trekking in below freezing conditions
I am going to be very honest here. The outside fresh water tank will freeze and anything in the grey or black tank in our Roadtrek will freeze at sustained temperatures below 32F (0C).  If the daytime goes well above freezing it will heat the tank contents and they may rise above freezing, but at night the temperature of the contents will fall as the outside ambient temperatures fall.  The contents may freeze. In other words, if both daytime and nighttime temperatures are sub freezing, then the outside fresh water tank, the grey tank, black tank, macerator, dump hose and under-chassis fresh water piping will freeze. Game Over!  The macerator cannot pump chunks of ice......

If we are trekking in sub freezing conditions, we winterize our 210P.  The inside fresh water tank can be used "in mild freezing conditions" according to my Roadtrek manual. However, there are restrictions. We do not use fresh water in the interior tank in the winter. We winterize the entire water system and carry portable containers of water. We add antifreeze to the gray and black tanks and use the sinks and toilet sparingly.  I carry two gallons of pink antifreeze with me. Sanitary wipes are a good substitute for running water for additional cleaning of hands, etc. 

Roadtrek's manual about Winter Use
Here is some of the text of the Roadtrek manual for my 2013 210P (from page G-2). This is provided as an illustration and your manual may differ:

"WINTER USE: (Moderate Subfreezing Conditions, -10C (14 F)):
The dual tank system allows you to use the fresh tank system under moderate subfreezing conditions by allowing you to isolate and drain the exterior fresh water tank.
During winter use:
  • Use gravity fill of interior tank only. [My Comment: This tank has about 10 gallon capacity and that gravity fill is on the right rear door jamb. Adding water to this tank requires a fully open rear door while pouring water via a funnel or container with attached hose into the fill point. This is not something I want to do in sub freezing conditions].
  • No outdoor shower (close the "mystery valves").
  • Waste water tanks are unprotected from freezing unless charged with antifreeze.
  • Interior temp must be maintained above 65F (18 C). 
  • Fridge must be turned ON.
  • Exterior fresh tank must be drained.
  • Exterior shower and city fill valves (Picture G-P7) must be closed and shower and city fill (See Picture G-P0) must be drained. 
  • To drain the city fill, depress the center of the check valve (figure G-P0) with a finger or blunt object to release the pressure and drain the water or antifreeze."  
  • [There is additional info in the manual and additional steps] "To prepare your motorhomes fresh water system for winter use you must do the following:"   [See 2010-2013 210P Manual Page G-2]....This is basically about winterizing the Roadtrek. 
Avoiding freezing of the gray and black tanks
Using portable fresh water containers (1 gallon or so) and then adding pink antifreeze to the gray and black may forestall freezing of other liquids added to those tanks, but there is no certainty. Furthermore, there are limits to the capacity of the grey and black tanks. Pink anti-freeze is good to about -51 F.  If we add pink antifreeze to our toilet after use, that will improve the freeze temperature of the black tank contents, but the antifreeze has been diluted and is no longer capable down to -51F.

The gray tank in my 210P has 23 US gallons capacity. The black tank has 10 US gallons capacity. When those tanks are full, we are then required to find running water and toilet facilities in fast food restaurants, restaurants, truck stops and so on, until the tanks are dumped. Some campgrounds do keep their bath and toilet facilities open in sub freezing conditions; some simply shut down for the winter.

Blog Post about Winterizing
http://roadtrek210.blogspot.com/2018/10/winterizing-water-system.html

What to do if we do get caught in a weather change to sub freezing conditions?
This happened to us once. We weren't winterized and we determined a sudden weather pattern change had occurred and sub freezing weather was coming. Predictions indicated we would experience lows below 15F for several days, unless we could travel out of the cold zone. This gave us mere hours to winterize. We dumped the fresh water tanks and water heater and then added pink (potable) anti freeze to the fresh system and the gray and black tanks, which did have some liquid in them.

But what if we had no pink anti freeze? In that case I would have dumped the fresh water tanks, opened all faucets and drained as much fresh water from the system as possible by gravity and also with the water pump (don't forget those outside shower lines and valves). I would consider remaining stationary and run the engine in an attempt to keep the underbody warm, and that includes the gray and black tanks, and any exposed piping. I would also have kept the interior at above normal temperature. At that point I would have crossed my fingers.

There are practical limits to this approach. If the weather falls into continuous sub freezing conditions for more than a day, well, there is only so much gasoline in the tank, and when moving there will be no engine heat in most of the underbody area.  In other words, I prefer to winterize under controlled conditions.

Have you ever dumped the gray and black tanks in sub freezing conditions?
For one thing the macerator is outside and might be at sub freezing temperatures. For another, that standard, thick green Roadtrek dump hose will be very stiff and you may not be able to get it to stretch.

We cut off that green hose in the box and attached a "Thetford" Sanicon slinky hose, which can extend to about 20 feet. However, it too becomes stiff in very cold weather.

All that remains of the original dump hose. Sanicon is black hose attached at the right

Thetford Sanicon hose on my Roadtrek, fully extended

Comfort Tips
Our lowest recorded outside morning temperature, while trekking and overnighting in the Roadtrek; in the morning our outside temperature monitor said we were at 3 F. This was the official temperature in Roswell NM that morning:



How we deal with cool to cold weather
  • If you have a generator, keep it serviced and exercised. We have used our Onan 2.8 kW  in sub freezing conditions. Be sure you use oil rated for sub freezing if you are winter trekking. See the Onan manual about this.  I use Seafoam gasoline additive in the Chevy gas tank before exercising the generator, which assures there is additive in the carburetor bowl. If I use the Onan on a trek, when we stop and decide we won't be using it in the near future I add Seafoam to the gas tank again and run the generator and exercise it. This draws conditioned gasoline into the carburetor. In this manner I'm not adding Seafoam to my gas tank with every fill.  There are other additives, too. Use the one that you prefer. 
  • Make sure your batteries are in good condition. More on coach batteries later in this post. For even more information, I have other blog posts on the AGM batteries in my Roadtrek, charging, etc. 
  • We fill the propane tank before trekking and we conserve propane.  The hot water heater and the furnace require propane. So does the 3-way refrigerator if we are off the grid. The refrigerator works best on 120VAC or Propane. Running the refrigerator on 12VDC only can quickly draw down the coach batteries, so we avoid that. We don't use the dual burner cooktop. We save that precious propane commodity for comfort if trekking in cold weather. If we run out of propane the furnace won't work, nor will the hot water heater. Of course, we can run the Onan generator and we can heat water in the microwave if necessary but there is no substitute for the propane furnace if we are off of the grid and don't use the generator. 
  • We travel with the expectation that the Onan generator may not start; that's never happened, but there is always a first time. If the Onan doesn't start then we only have 12VDC and Propane as energy sources when we are off the grid. The vehicle engine can be run to heat the interior. Our portable electric heater is a maximum 1500W and the Suburban propane furnace is 16,000 BTU. The furnace provides about three times the heat of the electric portable heater.  But we only have about 8 gallons of propane on board (10 gallon tank 80% fill). 
  • I carry some spare parts and tools. I think some tools are essential, and I chose to carry a few spare parts, too. I have another blog post on this. A summary: I carry a spare anode for the hot water heater, assorted small batteries, fuses, wire, spare Thetford Sanicon hose, spare macerator pump, and an assortment of latches for this Roadtrek. Several lubricants (light oil, WD-40, lithium grease, silicone). Basic tools include screwdriver with replaceable bits including square, phillips, flat. A small hacksaw,  channel lock pliers, needle nose pliers, Volt-Ohm meter, ammeter, kill-a-watt electrical device, crescent wrench, socket set, 1-1/16 socket for anode, electrical tape, teflon pipe tape, duct tape, EternaBond White Mobile Home RV Rubber Roof Repair 4" wide, glues, assorted electrical connectors, crimping tool, soldering iron and solder, etc. etc. I probably carry more tools than most would, but when we stop I then use these tools for making any modifications I may desire. (Note: strictly speaking, WD-40 isn't a lubricant, but it is great for cleaning parts prior to applying a lubricant). I do carry two gallons of pink anti-freeze; we have had to re-winterize "on the fly" once, and having that allowed it to happen; we did it in a gas mart when a sudden weather change dropped temperatures from 50F to about 10F.
  • Insulating door blanket or folding mattress. Put an insulator against the interior of the rear door. The doors have little or no insulation and a lot of metal surfaces and glass. Use Reflectix in the rear windows. Metal conducts heat from the interior of the coach to the cold outside. This cools the interior. You will feel this. Because we sleep in the rear and immediately adjacent to those doors, anything that insulates them makes sleeping more comfortable.  We have used the folding mattress for the 1st and 2nd seat for this, placing it on its side and with the "wings" folded in. The long section is 37 inches wide, and each "wing" is about 18 inches wide.  The width is anywhere between 54 inches or wider when used this way:
Roadtrek Mattress vertical for use as insulator - demonstration
  • Add an electric heater if on shore power or the generator. The heat pump will only work to about 40F, but that isn't low enough to run the furnace, in my opinion. We use a 750/1500 watt 120V electric ceramic heater when the outside nighttime temperature falls below 40F.  Here's an example:
Typical small 740/1500 watt 120V heater


  • Use an electric blanket. This can really make a difference when it gets cold. When not in use we roll it up and put it in a carry bag. 
  • Dual control electric blanket (only one control shown).
  • Stage (sequence) the propane furnace. By setting the thermostat of the furnace at the lowest comfortable temperature while running the 120 VAC ceramic heater, it is possible to assure that the interior coach temperature doesn't fall too low and propane is conserved. If on shore power, the staging means that 120VAC electrical is used to heat the coach, and only if the temperature falls below what one thinks is comfortable will the furnace come on. For example, we set the "furnace" temperature at 65F while the ceramic electric heater is set higher.  However, the Roadtrek Dometic thermostat is very flexible. It can run the furnace, or it can run the furnace plus the heat pump fan, or it can run the heat pump fan continuously. One needs to set the the thermostat to accomplish this. We prefer to run only the furnace in winter. How to do this? To do so requires than one reads the thermostat manual. (If you don't have one, google or Bing "Dometic RV Thermostat" and you will be directed to YouTube videos, etc. If you google or Bing "Dometic RV Thermostat Manual" you will be directed to pdf files, etc. which provide instruction and can be viewed or downloaded). 
Dometic Thermostat
  • Use a small multi-speed 12V fan to circulate air and minimize cold spots.  This small fan fits in the channel above the side entry door. The discharge is moveable. I also have a 12V extension to reach the dash power connector. 

12V DC Portable Fan


  • A couple of versions of soft insulated grocery bags. We carry these with us and use them for shopping and extra storage for soft goods, extra groceries, etc. If the refrigerator should encounter issues we can transfer food to these and add ice, or if we want to carry cold beverages or extra vegetables, etc. we can use these.  


Insulated bags for groceries

Maintain ventilation and reduce moisture - avoid condensation
Everything we do in a RV results in moisture release into the air. Even exhaling releases moisture and that will raise the internal humidity. Cooking with propane releases moisture because one of the byproducts of burning propane is water vapor.  Cooking and boiling liquids will release water vapor into the interior.

It is important to keep this free moisture under control. Excessive moisture condenses on cold surfaces such as windows. It also adds to discomfiture because damp clothing will conduct heat from our bodies faster than dry clothing. "Cotton kills" is the old backpacking expression.

Easiest way to eliminate excess moisture that has built up in the interior is to keep the roof vent open. However in cold weather this will also release internal heat. So we prefer to avoid doing this.  If we adjust our approach to prevent interior moisture from building up, then simply normal in and out via the side door is sufficient to vent.  However, I don't put Reflectix on that side passenger door window. I can "pop" the window if I want to admit outside fresh air.

One can run the roof fan if things get out of hand. We added a Maxx-Air vent cover so we don't worry about wind or snow or sleet getting into the rig while the fan lid is "open." That works with keeping birds and insects out, too.  The also allows us to easily open the fan vent cover even in the worst weather conditions.
Vent Cover
Cooking techniques to reduce interior moisture and reduce condensation. 
Cooking can be a significant source of interior moisture. Because burning propane releases water vapor (it is a byproduct of combustion) we don't use the propane range top. Instead we use:
  • Induction electric burner with cast iron.
  • Microwave convection oven.
Cast iron. Easy to clean, does require seasoning after repeated use and cleaning. Use a small amount of oil, spread it on the interior and heat until it is glazed.  We cover the food when cooking to reduce moisture release into the interior.
Induction electric burner with cast iron griddle
Grilled Steak on inductive cooktop

Can cook almost everything with cast iron, even outdoors if it is dry
cover removed for photo


Microwave convection oven. Great for boiling water and general cooking. Again, we do keep things covered. A silicon vegetable cooker works well.


Silicone for cooking vegetables in the microwave
Convection Chicken



Understand Your Heat Sources
In our Roadtrek we have several heat sources. We added two more:
  • Solar (sun striking the van and entering through windows),
  • Heat Pump,
  • Propane Furnace,
  • Thermostat (which controls the above),
  • 120V ceramic electrical heater (which we added),
  • Dual control electric blanket (which we added),
  • Reflectix. This doesn't add heat, but it does reduce heat loss, which is as valuable as any of the above,
  • 250 Watt electric radiating panel (which we use in our TT and 5th wheel),
  • Programmable 120V thermostat (which we use in our TT and 5th wheel to control the radiating panel).
The last two above are something to consider if you want an alternative to the 120V ceramic heater, or something to radiate energy into the sleeping area. However, the surface of these panels can get very hot. Which is why I have yet to use it in the small confines of the Roadtrek.

Sources of  Energy for heating and cooling
The sources of energy are what one has to rely upon in cool to cold weather. These include:
  • Vehicle engine heat
  • 120VAC shore power
  • 120VAC generator
  • Propane
  • Solar heat or solar power
  • 12V coach batteries (powers the furnace, etc.)
To heat the coach there has to be sufficient coach electrical energy available. For example, the propane furnace has a 12VDC blower and 12VDC ignition system. No 12VDC means no heat. These 12VDC systems will charge if on shore power, a generator or via solar. But when night falls, one must have sufficient electrical energy available. Or spend the night in sleeping bags.  I carry one sleeping bag, but we've never used it when trekking together. I have used it while "boondocking" alone.

As anyone who has spent any time winter camping can attest, merely sleeping in bags means a lot of moisture we exhale will condense and freeze on any cold surface. Back when tenting, we'd hang a towel over us to collect most of that moisture which was exhaled. The moisture was collected and froze on the towel......

In a RV moisture will collect and freeze on the coldest surfaces, and that includes the glass windows of your RV.

Solar Heat
We can benefit from solar energy. Parking with the RV facing the sun, so those solar rays enter the front of the RV can be very beneficial during daylight. Infrared energy turns to heat upon striking a solid object, be that the floor or the chairs, or you. (I'm not going to get into descriptions of black body energy situations, which are not useful for real world trekking).

Know the condition of your coach batteries
Batteries are extremely important if we are not connected to AC shore power, running the vehicle engine or an Onan generator. If fully charged, your batteries may provide you with sufficient 12VDC for the night, if you are not on 120VAC. However, repeatedly discharging AGM batteries below 50% will reduce their lifespan and capacity. For that reason I use a digital meter to determine the actual coach battery voltage. This provides me with the knowledge of when I really should begin recharging them. The lightbar in the Roadtrek is not sufficient in my opinion.

Here's some approximate battery data for AGM batteries:
  • Full charge = 13.00 V.
  • 80% charge = 12.50 V.
  • 50% charge = 12.05V (minimum for extended battery life).
  • 25% charge = 11.75V.
Roadtrek battery voltage (condition) indicator and alternatives:
Roadtrek Battery Voltage Indicator - very rough indication


Plug-in battery voltmeter, inexpensive, at Amazon and elsewhere

Location of 12V socket in  my 210P. Use a "splitter" to connect two things to this socket,
this is the location to plug in the 12V DC voltmeter



Our current coach battery monitor - measures and displays voltage and amperes.


Know the outside, interior and refrigerator temperatures
We have a couple of different approaches. The first is a typical time/date and temperature thermometer which includes a remote battery powered sensor. The remote can be put in an outside compartment to provide some idea of the outside temperature. In the photo taken at 6:38 am local time, the inside is 78.1F and the outside compartment is 15.4F. The actual outside temperature was lower.  We monitor the refrigerator temperature. This is more critical in hot weather. We simply want to avoid spoilage if something goes wrong and the temperature increases. We like to avoid unplanned stops. We carry a soft cooler bag for purchasing groceries, and we can always put critical food in it with ice if a refrigerator malfunction should occur. 

Coach and outside compartment temperature monitor - remote monitor is in outside compartment

Here's another inexpensive inside/outside digital thermometer. We use this to monitor the refrigerator, but the remote could certainly be used for outside temperature monitoring:

Temperature monitor with remote - we place the remote in the refrigerator
A real camping experience in an all electric Class B
This is what early morning in an all electric class B (not a Roadtrek) with solar panels and a small ceramic heater was like. We were on shore power. We've significantly improved on this:
Dawn at about 18F outside and cool inside
Here is the way it is in our Roadtrek, under similar conditions, after our improvements and adjustments. We were either on shore power or running the generator at the time of the photo:
Snug

Another Dawn - 33F, preparing to depart

Frozen in Texas
Frozen in Southern Indiana

Cold and damp in Georgia

Plugged in below freezing - that electric cord is very stiff at 15F. We are not using exterior water

Dawn,  6 F, the Reflectix has been stowed and we are about to move on

Having left the campground, we are headed to warmer conditions

Note:

  1. I've made a few updates, to expand the post. 10/23/2019.




Disclaimer
I am not promoting winter camping. This post is about being comfortable in cool to cold weather and about the things we did to make our Roadtrek more comfortable in such conditions. There are other issues, including winterizing the water systems when it gets cold. The most recent Roadtrek manuals detail this very well, and are available on the Roadtrek official company website. I have a post about this.

Are we happy about trekking in below freezing conditions? We are very pleased with the ability of the 210P to keep us comfortable in cool to cold weather. We are also satisfied with the steps we have taken to improve our comfort and and we handle winter issues very well in the 210P.  It has been a learning experience and using some common sense.  We prefer to move beyond cold weather as quickly as practical when we do encounter it.......


Copyright (c) 2019 Norman Retzke "All Rights Reserved" See the disclaimer for this blog,
http://roadtrek210.blogspot.com/

Thursday, October 17, 2019

Cargo Carrier Addition to RV - GVWR and OCCC



Rumble  Seat - This was the test for the carrier. We transported this to our summer lily pad, about 120 miles.

Bookmark and Share

The door does clear the carrier and the cargo and can be fully opened

We decided to add a cargo carrier. This was for use on our longer treks with the goal to move some of the stuff we transport out of the Roadtrek and free up interior space, or allow us to carry a few more things on longer treks. We find ourselves carrying "all weather" gear or an inflatable canoe and we usually don't need it until we arrive at our destination.  

We had no need to transport both bicycles and a carrier. If that was a requirement there are carriers with hitches that can simultaneously accommodate a bike rack, but we keep bicycles at each of our "lily pads". We can remove the cargo carrier and install the bike carrier if we desire.

Bicycle Carrier while in Florida

After some research I went with a "Haul Master" Heavy Duty Cargo Carrier from Harbor Freight.  The version I chose weighs about 50 lbs and folds.  Note: "Some assembly required".  Be aware that the weight capacity is determined in part by the hitch and capacity of the vehicle. I have no intention of loading the carrier beyond about 200 lbs. 

There are specifications for each Roadtrek which ultimately determine how much weight the vehicle can carry. I've included the specs for my 210P here. Because all of the weight of the carrier will be on the axles, I need to be mindful of the vehicle load.  One way to avoid exceeding the load specifications of my Roadtrek is to carry less fluids (water, waste).  The fresh water in my 210 can weigh 250 lbs. (30 gallons fresh water at 8.345 lbs per gallon). The 33 gallons gray + black tanks can add another 275 lbs).

A hitch extension is required to clear the tire carrier. I chose a rugged, slightly longer than necessary Curtis.  This adds 18 inches from pin to pin and allows me to open the right rear door completely with the carrier in the horizontal position.  The price of the carrier and a rugged nylon cover was less than $99 because of a sale and I also had a coupon.  To that I added the cost of the Curtis extension,  pin locks and nylon webbing tie-downs.

My selection criteria included:
  • Intermittent use and easy storage when not in use.
  • Flexibility for intended use.
  • Basket dimensions approximately 19 x 60 inches.
  • Rear door access when the carrier is on the Roadtrek.
  • To be within allowable vehicle weight limits.
  • Modest cost.
Cargo carrier specifications:
  • Cargo space approximately 19" x 60".
  • Weight Capacity: 450 Lb on 2 inch Class III hitch with 500 Lb. Tongue. (Higher with a Class IV hitch).
  • Foldable.
  • Assembly Required.
  • Weight of cargo carrier 50 lbs, with hitch extension total about 70 lbs.
An extension was necessary to clear the tire carrier.  I used one longer than necessary. My decision to use an extension required a reduction in the amount of weight on the the carrier. The actual weight limit is a consequence of the hitch on the Roadtrek, the extension, and the carrier.

My Roadtrek 210P has a 2 inch receiver Class IV hitch.  These are the specifications according to the information provided with the vehicle by Roadtrek and Chevrolet. Your specification are probably different:

  • 6.0 L V-8 engine on 3500 extended chassis (155" wheelbase) with 3.42 Axle Ratio.
  • "Towing - Tow Weight" approximately 7,650 lbs. Note: this is approximate, as the GCWR must not be exceeded. Total weight of vehicle, contents and trailer must not exceed 16,000 lbs. That is per the specifications for my Roadtrek.
  • "Towing - Tongue Weight" is 1,000 lbs. (The extension reduces this, see below).
  • The GVWR (gross vehicle weight rating) is 9,600 lbs.
  • The OCCC (combined weigh of cargo, liquids, tongue weight and occupants) is 1,246 lbs.
  • GAWR front (Gross Axle Weight Rating, Front) is 4,300 lbs.
  • GAWR Rear (Gross Axle Weight Rating, Rear) is 6,084 lbs.
  • GCWR (Gross Combined Weight Rating, vehicle, passenger, contents and trailer) =  16,000 lbs.
Note: Check your 200, 210, 170 or 190 Roadtrek Chevrolet or Dodge Manual and Roadtrek data sheet for your model for actual towing limitations for your Roadtrek. Do not rely upon the specification for my 210P.

Here is a sample data sheet, based upon my vehicle. Use yours for determining the specifics for your Roadtrek. I have blocked out some vehicle specific identifying info:


Sample Data Sheet - My Roadtrek - Use yours to determine your Roadtrek data

According to Curtis, the extension reduces the tongue weight to a maximum 350 lbs. 

According to the carrier manual it is designed for a maximum 750 lbs with a Class IV  hitch and 450 lbs with a Class III hitch.  You could say it is overbuilt for my purpose. I wanted something sufficiently rugged. There is a trade-off using a heavier cargo carrier. The weight of the carrier, hitch extension, etc. is probably about 70 lbs.  This reduces the actual cargo weight I can safely transport in the carrier. 

I have no intentions of loading the carrier beyond 200 lbs. One issue is side-by-side weight distribution. Balancing loads is not always possible and that will put twisting moment into the hitch connections. I want to avoid those bending moments.

Photo of carrier in the down position. This has ample clearance to open the door, even with stuff in the carrier:



Photo of carrier in the up position. Note the ample clearance to the tire carrier:



Harbor Freight Photo of 54-1/2 In. Expandable Nylon Cargo Carrier Cover:
Some assembly required: I did this myself and it is important to realize that the assembled unit is about 50 lbs. Moving the major pieces around, attaching struts, etc. requires some upper body strength.  It went together well, as usual it is prudent to lay out the parts, plan the work and take one's time to do it properly.  The diagrams included were sufficient.  I used a crescent wrench and a socket set to do this.  The instructions recommend assembly on a flat surface. After putting the two main components together I raised the main assembly and leaned it against a wall so I could work on the struts which support it while I was standing.

In the box

Major components

Minor components
Copyright (c) 2019 Norman Retzke "All Rights Reserved" See disclaimers, etc. at the blog site
Roadtrek210P.blogspot.com

Wednesday, October 16, 2019

Wave Action - Winter is approaching





Bookmark and Share



Last night we experienced some serious wind with gusts of about 35-40 MPH.  This
morning after breakfast we headed to the lakeshore and with the winds from the northwest, there are predictions of 16 ft waves today.

Weather will improve tomorrow and we will experience sun and 60+F. However, we know this is the  end of this summer season. We will soon be shutting down the northern lily pad for the year, and we'll we leaving for warmer climes.....

Here's current conditions nearby:


5-day plot - Wind DirectionWind Direction (WDIR):NW ( 320 deg true )
5-day plot - Wind SpeedWind Speed (WSPD):25.3 kts
5-day plot - Wind GustWind Gust (GST):33.0 kts
5-day plot - Wave HeightWave Height (WVHT):9.5 ft
5-day plot - Dominant Wave PeriodDominant Wave Period (DPD):8 sec
5-day plot - Mean Wave DirectionMean Wave Direction (MWD):NNW ( 340 deg true )
5-day plot - Atmospheric PressureAtmospheric Pressure (PRES):29.83 in
5-day plot - Air TemperatureAir Temperature (ATMP):49.8 °F
5-day plot - Water TemperatureWater Temperature (WTMP):56.7 °F
5-day plot - Dew PointDew Point (DEWP):41.9 °F
5-day plot - Wind ChillWind Chill (CHILL):41.9 °F
5-day plot - Wind Speed at 10 MetersWind Speed at 10 meters (WSPD10M):29.1 kts
5-day plot - Wind Speed at 10 MetersWind Speed at 20 meters (WSPD20M):31.1 kts
5-day plot - Wind Speed, Wind Gust and Atmospheric PressureCombined plot of Wind Speed, Gust, and Air Pressure


Morning buoy photo


Buoy photo 4:03PM
By the morning of the 18th, the lake had finally calmed down:



Sunday, October 6, 2019

Roadtrek Wooden Cabinets - Replacements

https://www.cutritewoodworking.com/


Bookmark and Share



"𝗪𝗲 𝗮𝗿𝗲 𝗰𝗮𝗽𝗮𝗯𝗹𝗲 𝗼𝗳 𝗺𝗮𝘁𝗰𝗵𝗶𝗻𝗴 𝗽𝗿𝗲𝘃𝗶𝗼𝘂𝘀 𝗶𝘁𝗲𝗺𝘀 𝘁𝗵𝗮𝘁 𝗺𝗮𝘆 𝗵𝗮𝘃𝗲 𝗯𝗲𝗰𝗼𝗺𝗲 𝗱𝗮𝗺𝗮𝗴𝗲𝗱 𝗮𝗻𝗱 𝗻𝗲𝗲𝗱 𝗿𝗲𝗽𝗹𝗮𝗰𝗶𝗻𝗴. 𝗜𝘁𝗲𝗺𝘀 𝘁𝗵𝗮𝘁 𝘁𝗵𝗶𝘀 "𝗻𝗲𝘄" 𝗥𝗼𝗮𝗱𝘁𝗿𝗲𝗸 𝗰𝗮𝗻𝗻𝗼𝘁 𝗼𝗿 𝘄𝗶𝗹𝗹 𝗻𝗼𝘁 𝗿𝗲𝗽𝗹𝗮𝗰𝗲."

I'm a member of the FMCA, Roadtrek Chapter. One of the members passed along this info from Cutrite Woodworking In Waterloo, Ontario Canada. If you cannot get wood products for your older Roadtrek, from the "new" Roadtrek Company, this is a possible source. I'm merely passing this along as a "service", I have no interest in the company. The emphasis below is mine:

"For well over 25 years we have been manufacturing all the solid wood components for Roadtrek RVs (Home and Park) locally here in the KW area in Ontario, Canada.......𝗪𝗲 𝗮𝗿𝗲 𝘀𝘁𝗶𝗹𝗹 𝗰𝗮𝗽𝗮𝗯𝗹𝗲 𝗼𝗳 𝗽𝗿𝗼𝗱𝘂𝗰𝗶𝗻𝗴 𝗮𝗹𝗹 𝗼𝗳 𝘁𝗵𝗲 𝘄𝗼𝗼𝗱𝗲𝗻 𝗰𝗼𝗺𝗽𝗼𝗻𝗲𝗻𝘁𝘀 𝘁𝗼 𝗼𝗿𝗶𝗴𝗶𝗻𝗮𝗹 𝘀𝗽𝗲𝗰𝗶𝗳𝗶𝗰𝗮𝘁𝗶𝗼𝗻𝘀. 𝗢𝘃𝗲𝗿 𝘁𝗵𝗲 𝘆𝗲𝗮𝗿𝘀 𝘄𝗲 𝗵𝗮𝘃𝗲 𝘀𝘂𝗽𝗽𝗹𝗶𝗲𝗱 𝗥𝗼𝗮𝗱𝘁𝗿𝗲𝗸 𝘄𝗶𝘁𝗵 𝗼𝗮𝗸, 𝗺𝗮𝗽𝗹𝗲, 𝗮𝗻𝗱 𝗿𝗲𝗰𝗲𝗻𝘁𝗹𝘆 𝗶𝗻 𝗮 𝗺𝗶𝘅𝘁𝘂𝗿𝗲 𝗼𝗳 𝘄𝗼𝗼𝗱𝘀, 𝘀𝘁𝘆𝗹𝗲𝘀 𝗮𝗻𝗱 𝗺𝗮𝗻𝘆 𝗰𝗼𝗹𝗼𝘂𝗿𝘀, 𝗶𝗻𝗰𝗹𝘂𝗱𝗶𝗻𝗴 𝗯𝗿𝗼𝘄𝗻, 𝗯𝗹𝗮𝗰𝗸, 𝘄𝗵𝗶𝘁𝗲 𝗮𝗻𝗱 𝗲𝘃𝗲𝗻 𝗰𝗿𝗲𝗮𝗺. We produce all our products 100% locally from start to finish, and deliver straight from our manufacturing facility to all our customers throughout Ontario. The components we have been building exclusively for Roadtrek included all styles and colours of cabinet doors, solid drawer fronts, and all the trim.

As you are surely aware of, Roadtrek will start production under new ownership and has informed us that we will continue to supply them once again.

𝗪𝗲 𝗮𝗿𝗲 𝗰𝗮𝗽𝗮𝗯𝗹𝗲 𝗼𝗳 𝗺𝗮𝘁𝗰𝗵𝗶𝗻𝗴 𝗽𝗿𝗲𝘃𝗶𝗼𝘂𝘀 𝗶𝘁𝗲𝗺𝘀 𝘁𝗵𝗮𝘁 𝗺𝗮𝘆 𝗵𝗮𝘃𝗲 𝗯𝗲𝗰𝗼𝗺𝗲 𝗱𝗮𝗺𝗮𝗴𝗲𝗱 𝗮𝗻𝗱 𝗻𝗲𝗲𝗱 𝗿𝗲𝗽𝗹𝗮𝗰𝗶𝗻𝗴. 𝗜𝘁𝗲𝗺𝘀 𝘁𝗵𝗮𝘁 𝘁𝗵𝗶𝘀 "𝗻𝗲𝘄" 𝗥𝗼𝗮𝗱𝘁𝗿𝗲𝗸 𝗰𝗮𝗻𝗻𝗼𝘁 𝗼𝗿 𝘄𝗶𝗹𝗹 𝗻𝗼𝘁 𝗿𝗲𝗽𝗹𝗮𝗰𝗲.

I am not trying to sell anything nor am I pushing the product, I am merely informing you and your members that we are here to help in any way possible.

We are:
Cutrite Woodworking
Waterloo, Ontario
1-800-[xxx-xxxx]
519-747-4891

The website is currently under construction:
https://www.cutritewoodworking.com/

Friday, October 4, 2019

Sedona Arizona - Pink Jeep Tours




Ready to begin our Pink Jeep Tour

Bookmark and Share



One of the opportunities when visiting Sedona is to take a jeep tour. We took two opportunities via Pink Jeep Tours.  There were different venues. Some are more bouncy than others.  The first was a somewhat mild, shorter jeep excursion. However, after that we were ready for the "Rim 2.0" tour which is so named because it is two hours in length and take one up into the bluffs above Sedona.

Both tours were fun. The second provided wonderful vistas, which is why we decided to take it.  Pink Jeep offers a discount for second tours so we took advantage of that promotion.

These jeeps can hold six in the rear and a seventh in the passengers seat, adjacent to the driver. For this reason our tours consisted of two family groups. All the seating locations provide good views, seatbelts and ample hand grips. The rearmost seats are more bouncy than the front seats, which children enjoy. On the first trek I had the opportunity to sit in the front passenger seat.  For the rim tour G got the front passenger seat.  That seat provides the most thrilling front facing view. LOL!


Ready for the first of two tours. G is excited!  Our driver was Kyle. Great Job!
First, short Pink Jeep Tour:



Second, and longer Pink Jeep Tour. Interrupted by a Neiman Marcus photoshoot - LOL:




Thursday, September 26, 2019

Orphaned Roadtrek Chevy Owners Group Notice



Bookmark and Share



I claim ownership of all original material on this blog.   Furthermore, most original photos contain my watermark. All material on this blog is copyrighted by me or the respective owners. Copying it and placing copied files on Social Group websites other website or blogs is prohibited...

The content of this site including articles and diagrams or. photographs by the author are Copyrighted by this site. If you wish to copy or print any of the articles found on this site you may do so for personal use only.  If you wish to share any of the content on this site you may do so for personal use only if and only if you include a reference to this website as to where the information and content has come from - that is:

"http://Roadtrek210.blogspot.com"
and "Roadtrekking 210 Blog"

Any COMMERCIAL USE of anything found on this site is prohibited without prior written permission from this site which can be requested by email Thank you!

===========================================================

A facebook group Administrator for  "Orphaned Roadtrek Chevy Owners" asked permission to copy the contents of blog articles and place the resulting PDF files on their group.

Yesterday, September 25, 2019 I Declined that request and stated to the Administrator "Carlos M. Fernandez" in writing that I claim ownership for all of the material on this blog. I also have watermarks in most of the photos which are originals and will protect the rights of others who have contributed to this blog.  I pointed out that I want to retain control of the content of this blog and that I do make updates or improvements to old articles from time to time.  I want readers to get the most helpful and accurate content.  Obviously, when someone copies this content they remove that opportunity and it is possible old and less reliable information will be passed along.

I counteroffered and suggested that the group make a searchable pdf with links to articles of interest on this blog and others. That file could be stored on the group file location and accessed by all members of the group. However, the group administrator(s) apparently decided to do otherwise....

Today I discovered that I cannot access the group. Apparently the Administrator of "Orphaned Roadtrek Chevy Owners" has blocked me from that group. In other words, their request to copy the contents of this blog was not a request. It was in fact a demand.

The Copyright Notice is at the bottom of every page of my blog, which consists of several posts.  This blog has contained a copyright notice since the date of inception in 2013:

(c) NORM60189, NORMR60189 2013, 2015, 2017. 2019 Simple theme. Powered by Blogger.

Piracy is a crime, people.....

Copyright 2019 "All Rights Reserved"

Article originally posted September 26, 2019


Original material:  https://roadtrek210.blogspot.com/

Wednesday, September 25, 2019

Wi-Fi Connection Difficulties




Unlimited Streaming Possibilities - But not at the Campgrounds!

Bookmark and Share





Original material:  https://roadtrek210.blogspot.com/

If you are like us, you have encountered campgrounds that advertise wi-fi but internet access is non-existent or very sloooooooow. More often than not, the issue is streaming by campers....

Here is my "home" internet speed, with four devices connected. You will not experience this at the typical campground, yet this is what many campers expect:


This post is prompted by a recent experience at a campground which had upgraded the wi-fi system. Some campers were thrilled and immediately connected their TVs so they could stream movies. One camper even posted a photo of their internet enabled TV.......Well, you can guess how that turned out. Soon we were all once again plodding along with poor connections, as apparently everyone attempted to stream movies and videos.

I discussed this with the campground management who said "Norm thanks again for the information but I have no clue. I'm not a tech kind of guy. For 32 years ...I turned all this stuff over to the IT department. As I did here..... My [contract] with this company was to provide  a stronger WYFI signal and to reach a broader scope of campers. Seems that both of those objectives have been met. Does it meet everyone expectations.  No!!! But certainly better [than]it was. "

I made three posts on the Facebook page of the campground to advise campers of the limitations. This blog article is based upon that.

When that campground upgraded one camper posted "Thanks for the great WiFi..I think I may never leave.." They included a photo of their streaming TV:

Streaming TV at the Campground?? Good Luck!
We usually encounter slow speeds at campgrounds in which all campers sign on with a common user name and password. In this situation the internet connection is shared without individual restrictions between all the users in the campsites. In other words, there are no bandwidth restrictions on any one user and if you want to stream, go for it. However, this shared connection probably won't allow us all to stream movies at the same time. For example, it can be expected that smaller campgrounds have a total bandwidth of about 60 MB/sec (60 Megabytes per second).

In the campground, if we all attempt to open the cold water at the sink at the same time the water flow drops to a trickle. The same thing happens with the internet connection. That internet "pipeline" has only so much capacity.

You may ask "How many users can that support?"

Not all of us can stream at the same time. I think there may be a misunderstanding about this. I'm going to include some figures later in this post. This post is the background information so you, the reader understand what those numbers will mean to you.


As additional users log in with their smartphones, PCs, tablets and internet enabled TVs the internet bandwidth is shared. In simple terms, if 60 people sign into a shared system that 60 MB/sec is divided among 60 devices and each of us gets 1.0 MB/sec internet speed. The actual allocation can be more complex.

If a campground with 60 sites has two people at each site and one is using a smartphone on the internet and the other a PC or internet enabled TV, then at those times the campground is full we could have 120 or more users logged into the wi-fi and internet service. In that case, we might each get only 0.5 MB/sec. However, the bandwidth may not be shared equally.

To demonstrate, the photo below shows the actual internet speed at a recent campground at about 6:30PM. That is distinct from the wi-fi connection speed. The campground has a wi-fi system that connects to an internet provider (ISP) via a modem. The campground wi-fi speed and the internet speed are not the same.

At the time I took the screen shot the internet speed was 4.3 MB/sec. At the same time the wi-fi speed on my PC was 27 MB/sec. In other words, the campground internet connection is the ultimate deciding factor about how much bandwidth is available. It was being shared by all of us who were logged in at the time, and my portion was 4.3 MB per second.

Internet campground speed as checked at FAST.COM

I’m providing this info to pass along to anyone having a camp wifi connection issue. Of course, if they aren’t connected they would need someone to pass this info to them.

At a recent campground with few users plugged in, the wi-fi was fast, really fast (see the photo). Speeds will vary.

However, as people got up and connected the speed dropped dramatically. You may experience connecting issues as we did. For one thing, there are different wifi (WLan) standards. Some of these are backwards compatible and some are not. I have no idea what campgrounds have installed, and apparently neither do some of the management. Knowing the bands and protocols of campground hardware would certainly aid in solving connection issues.....
Internet speed at a campground with most campers asleep and disconnected!

In other words, our ability to connect to the campground wi-fi will be determined in part by the compatibility of the hardware we are using to whatever the camp owners have installed.


However, here’s a few things to be aware of.
  1. The wi-fi signals can experience interference. The strength can be reduced by metal walls and so on. At another resort we know of people who live in “candominiums” with metal walls who experience issues with cell phones, wi-fi and so on. Some campers have aluminum sides. The signals are “line of sight” so if the network router is behind a building, or another structure or blocked by other rigs you may not get a signal or it will be greatly diminished (very weak). Weak signals do “come and go” which can be really annoying. You may get a better as in stronger and more reliable signal by moving your hardware to another table, etc. Try setting up your laptop or whatever outside of your rig. If that solves the problem then you know it is structural interference.
  2. Rebooting (power off ,then power on) can sometimes help, as does a kick to the head.....
  3. There are different wifi communications bands. The wi-fi source such as the campground may support only one band or both. There are 2.4GHz and 5 GHz (Giga-Hertz) bands. If your hardware is designed for 2.4 GHz and the campground is 5 GHz, then your hardware won’t see the new network. Consider it to be like attempting to use an AM radio to listen to an FM station. On questioning the owner at a recent campground he could not tell me what hardware is installed, but I suspect it is single band 5GHz. If so, it will be invisible to any 2.4GHz hardware (TV, PC, etc).
  4. When you bring up a list of available wi-fi “hotspots” what you see is a list of SSIDs. These are “service set identifiers” for the available networks. Each network device may broadcast that SSID. If you do see the SSID for the campground you should be able to connect to the network if your hardware is using the proper encryption and you have the proper password. Many campgrounds use WPA2 PSK encryption. Most campgrounds use a log on name and a password. You must use these.
  5. There are a number of standards for wi-fi data link protocols and these have evolved over time. Current standards include IEEE 802.11a, but there is also 802.11b, 802.11g, 802.11n, 802.11ac and 802.11ax. Older hardware may not be compliant with newer protocols and that means you may have connection issues. You may see the SSID but there will be connection problems. Some network technology (routers, etc.) are backwards compatible to different standards. It is likely the campground management will be unable to tell you what they have installed, but it doesn't hurt to ask.
Why is Streaming a problem?
I hope this clarifies a few things. Realistic expectations will aid us in having a pleasant internet surfing experience while at the campground.  Streaming is what is called a "data hog".

Netflix and YouTube say we will each use the following bandwidth, if we attempt to stream using these services. Amazon Prime, Hulu, HBO and so on are similar to Netflix. Music services such as Pandora also use bandwidth, between 150 and 300 kbps (0.150 to 0.300 MB/sec).

Netflix Requirements (Prime and Hulu are similar):
  1. Required minimum connection speed 0.5 Megabits per second. Below this you won’t be able to connect to the Netflix website. Recommended connection speed 1.5 Megabits per second.
  2. SD (standard) or DVD quality streaming 3.0 Megabits per second.
  3. HD Quality 5.0 Megabits per second.
  4. Ultra HD Quality 25 Megabits per second.

YouTube Requirements:
  1. SD 360 requires 0.7 Megabits per second.
  2. HD 720p requires 2.5 Megabits per second (this is average quality).
  3. HD 1080p requires 5.0 Megabits per second.
  4. 4K requires 20 Megabits per second.

At a recent campground I concluded the peak internet speed for the entire network was 60 MB/sec (60 Megabits per second). I monitored it for a few days and the normal is about 20MB/sec, but at times when logging on my connection speed would drop to as low as 1 MB/sec..

To provide perspective we have camped in many, many locations from the north to the southwest, the eastern seaboard to the Florida Keys and everything in between. Internet access is frequently a touch and go thing, which is why I have a Verizon jetpack….Because of my business travel situation for many years I travelled with both AT&T and Verizon!  However, even cellular systems can become overloaded.  Comcast Xfinity has connection points all over their geographical area, but you will find connect speed of about 1.0 MN/sec. That has been my experience.

Some older campgrounds have DSL (Digital Subscriber Line) internet service, which is via telephone line and is distributed throughout the campground. It does require a DSL modem to connect. Those systems usually have individual login and passwords, and the routers provide download speeds beginning at about 4.0 MB/sec. That is adequate for streaming on one device at a time.  I say that from practical experience gained.

Speed Decreases as more users are added

I stated that our wi-fi, common log on internet speed will decrease as more of us add devices to the campground system. The bandwidth is shared among all of us who are connected. As more of us perform streaming tasks such as movies, videos, music and so on, the speed for each of us decreases, until the connections falter.

This is exactly what we have experienced in wi-fi systems. Some systems have greater bandwidth and more of us can connect than before. However, it is not infinite and we will experience slow downs and interruptions as more of us stream and “pile on”. The campground’s ISP (internet service provider) may also “throttle” or reduce the bandwidth as more is used. That would aggravate the situation, making it worse for each connected user (that’s you and me).

What does this mean in realistic terms, as we attempt to stream movies? If a campground has a 60 MB bandwidth to the internet, then we each might have a connection speed of 1.0 MB per second if 60 of us (including the campground owners) attempt to login to the internet and simultaneously run content. At 20 MB/sec the internet speed for each of us will be about 1/3 of that…..

What can we each do with a 1.0 MB/sec connection? We can’t stream movies……To stream we would need about 3.0 MB/sec on Netflix (DVD quality, but not HD). It would seem that about 20 users might be able to stream movies at a time on the new campground internet service. 

I hope this clarifies a few things. Realistic expectations will make our internet surfing a pleasant experience.

Remember, when all else fails:



Copyright (C) 2019 Norman Retzke "All Rights Reserved"