7 Pages are shown on the Main Page.

7 pages are shown on the Main Page. To see additional posts, click on the link "Older Posts" at the bottom of the main page. For videos go to https://www.youtube.com/@normanretzke4377/videos click "skip" to avoid ads


G has a "swell" time kayaking

G has a "swell" time kayaking
G has a "swell" time on Lake Michigan in an inflatable canoe

Dawn on the Gulf of Mexico

Dawn on the Gulf of Mexico
Dawn on the Gulf of Mexico

Warren Dunes Sunset

Warren Dunes Sunset
Warren Dunes Sunset

Sunday, October 25, 2015

Lithium Batteries and Solar Power, Revisited




Bookmark and Share




Winter approaches and we are near the end of our first two years with a camper van. It is time to winterize and to review my "to do" list. One item has been improving the coach battery system. We did store the camper for two winters with the batteries on a solar panel.

This worked fairly well. But, I wasn't happy with the amount of power provided by these 220Ah batteries, and began exploring alternatives in late 2013, immediately on purchase. I'd done the numbers and knew we would be on the edge based upon our intended use of the vehicle. Why do I say "on the edge?" It is because of the available capacity of these batteries, which is not 220Ah if one wants them to have a reasonable life expectancy of 5 or more years.

A Short Review
What is the true available 12VDC power? 220Ah of AGM batteries can only provide 110Ah while keeping them above a "safe" discharge level of 50%.  What does that mean? If one wants to run some appliances and an inverter, the batteries can provide the following power:

  • 5 amperes (60 watts @ 12 volts) for 22 hours, or 
  • 6.5 amperes (78 watts @ 12 volts) for 16 hours, or 
  • 8.5 amperes (102 watts @ 12 volts) for 12 hours, or 
  • 12 amperes (144 watts @ 12 volts) for 8 hours. 
The real issue is having sufficient battery capacity to run necessities through the night while off shore power and without a generator. At a minimum this would be the refrigerator and a vent fan or the furnace plus some lighting. The loads of your rig might be different than mine. To run any 120V appliances including a PC would require the inverter which has losses as part of the process of converting 12VDC to 120VAC. It would be best to use 12VDC appliances and a PC which can run from 12VDC. We've got a propane range top and so we can use that for cooking. If the weather is mild, it is possible to use the propane BBQ or if allowed, a wood burning campfire. These things reduce the electrical requirements for the batteries. Of course, we can simply fire up the generator. However it is my desire to make it through a typical night in mild (40F to 85F) weather without shore power or running the generator. That is not necessarily a daily requirement. In fact, based on our actual experience. we only need overnight battery capacity on an occasional basis. That translates into the cost-benefit analysis of the battery and solar system.

The existing AGM batteries, if in excellent condition could provide about 6.5 amperes for 16 hours. I do need to emphasize that I am assuming the batteries are in good condition and fully charged. If not, then less power would be available. Why 16 hours? That's maximum for winter with darkness and operating on batteries from 5pm to 9am. I'm assuming cool temperatures in which there would be no need for supplemental coach heat beyond use of the furnace. However, I've done some analysis of our electric blanket and that is a viable alternative.

If my refrigerator operates on propane I do need some 12VDC for the controls. The furnace electronics and fan also require 12VDC. Lighting loads vary. I've got fluorescent and LEDs. In a pinch we could use hockey puck LED lights which run of AA batteries. But we don't want our "tiny home on wheels" to morph into "our tiny cave on wheels."

How Much DC Power is Used?

  • Suburban Furnace = 2.8A (intermittent)
  • Max-Air Fan @ Medium Speed = 1.5A
  • Refrigerator 12V electronics = estimated 1A
  • Propane/CO Alarm = 0.1A
  • Smoke Alarm = 0A (9V battery)

These  items consume 5.4 amperes. That is approaching the maximum 16 hour capacity of the batteries, and based upon experience that's a realistic maximum for daily hours with less than perfect batteries. It would seem that Roadtrek did a good job sizing this system. Remember that the furnace runs intermittently. That's why I didn't include the lighting load. However, if one uses the inverter, then the requirements increase by about 1.5 amperes or more. That's because of the inefficiency and losses in the inverter.

Do I Need Lithium Batteries?
Based upon our actual experience since December 2013, I would say that we do not. It is true that our current battery system is marginal. However, based upon actual needs, we don't need to do an upgrade at this time.

That said, it is possible I will replace the AGMs with LiFePO4 batteries when that time comes. Here is my reality: It is all about cost-benefit analysis. I do have a design and it will be easy to adjust the design as time goes on. With each design modification I'll get current prices and current technology.  Trigger events to upgrade would include battery failure, inverter/charger failure, a desire for more solar than I currently have, and so on.

It is also possible that some day I may take this on as a "hobby" project. But I am under no pressure to make the modifications at this time.

Here are some links to earlier posts on this subject:

http://roadtrek210.blogspot.com/2015/02/agm-battery-alternatives.html

http://roadtrek210.blogspot.com/2015/02/are-lithium-coach-batteries-expensive.html

Here is a handy calculator to help you determine how long your coach batteries can handle a specific load in amperes:

http://www.batterystuff.com/kb/tools/calculator-sizing-a-battery-to-a-load.html

Note: Edited amps used to add CO/Propane detector, misc.

No comments: